banner medium
Home About Jillian Portfolio North Shore Petitions Media Links Contact Search this site
Other Portfolio pages -  Ambulance Service of NSW 
Emergency Departments  
Hospital Acquired Infection 
Shadow Minister for Health
 
Waiting Lists

Health Issues ...

This page provides an overview of some of the major health issues. There are numerous links to assist you move to specific pages for more details, or you can use the 'go' list above.

On this page you can view a summary of:

What is happening in Hospitals ....

Since the Labor Government has been in office there has been a much bigger increase in admissions to private hospitals than to public hospitals ; only 32% of registered and enrolled nurses and midwives in NSW are choosing to work in the public health system and there are around 2,500 fewer beds in public hospitals ...

Admissions to Hospital ....

The State Government's health department annual reports show that between 1994-95 and 2008-09

  • Total Admission to hospital rose by 42%
  • Total Admissions toNSW Public Hospitals rose by 22%
  • Total Admissions to Private Hospitals rose by 93%
Admissions to public hospitals increase marginally while private hospital admissions nearly double 
 
1994-95
2008-09
Change since 94-95 
% change
Total Admissions NSW Public Hospitals
1,273,963
1,555,480
281,517
22.1%
Total Admissions Private Hospitals
483,579
934,738
451,159
93.3%
Total Admissions (Public + Private)
1,757,542
2,490,218
732,676
41.7%
% of all admissions using private hospitals
27.5%
37.5%
10.0%
36.4%

Admissions to Government Hospitals ....

public admissions

Admissions to Private Hospitals ....

private admissions

Shortage of nurses....

... only 32% of the Registered Nurses and Enrolled nurses in NSW are choosing to work in our public hospital system according to the 2007-08 department of health annual report.

Number of Nurses and Midwives in NSW 2008-09
Registered Nurses 86,488
Registered Midwives 17,535
Enrolled Nurses 17,250
Authorised Nurse Practitioners 131
Authorised Midwife Practitioners 2
Total Nurses in NSW 119,290
Employed in the NSW Public Health System 39,142
% of Nurses in NSW employed in the NSW Public Health System 32%
Source: NSW Health Annual Report 07-08 pages 247 and 260

nurses

The government is advertising nursing vacancies on the NSW Health website, despite offering experienced front-line nurses voluntary redundancies. The figures below were downloaded on June 14th 2010 from NSW Health website: http://www.health.nsw.gov.au/nursing/employment/dohrs.asp

Area Health Service: Positions being actively recruited (PAR)
MARCH 2010
Area Health Service  Total PAR*
Children's Hospital at Westmead 11.5
Justice Health 47.3
Sydney South West 135.7
South Eastern Sydney/Illawarra 207.1
Sydney West 57.5
Northern Sydney/Central Coast 87.7
Metro AHS 546.8
Hunter/New England 72.8
North Coast 107.2
Greater Southern 141.1
Greater Western 75.6
Rural Total 397
STATE TOTAL 994

Note* RN, EN and other nursing positions being actively recruited.

Public hospital bed numbers cut ....

... hospital bed numbers have been cut by 2,599 since the Carr Government was elected in 1995.

Average Available Beds in NSW Public Hospitals
Year
No.
88/89 (first year of Coalition Government) [Source: NSW Health annual report1989] 20,867
94-95 23,910
Change 1988-98 to 1994-95 (Carr Government elected) 3,043
95-96 23,536
96-97 22,496
97-98 21,965
98-99 21,222
99-00 21,254
00-01 19,720
01-02 19,513
02-03* 19,147
03-04* 19,370
04-05* 20,472
05-06* 20,563
06-07* 21,050
07-08* 21,397
08-09* 21,311
Change 94-95 to 08-09 -2,599
Source:1994-95 to 2000-01 figs from NSW Health annual report 2001 page 93; 2001-02 to 2007-08 figs from 2008-09 annual report page 259
** cots and bassinettes were included from 1 July 2002. There are an estimated 1,000 cots and they have been subtracted from this data from this date to enable comparison.

beds

Emergency Departments .....

Ask anyone what they regard as the most important aspect of health care and they'll tell you the ability to get emergency treatment when they need it.

Yet our Emergency Departments are failing to cope, many of them being gridlocked. Critically ill people are waiting longer than they should to be seen by doctors (or even being taken off Ambulance trolleys), they are having to wait in corridors, they can't be admitted to hospital wards because there aren't enough beds and sometimes it takes days for medical treatment.

There has been a marked deterioration in Emergency Department benchmarks (the measures the government uses to see how they are performing) since the LaborGovernment came to office, not because medical staff are not doing their best, but primarily because of a shortage of ward beds to receive patients that must be admitted to hospital. (see Emergency Departments for details)

Waiting Lists ....

Record numbers of people are waiting for elective treatment in our hospitals despite the Labor Government being elected in the first place on a promise to half them. And even worse, there are many more people on those lists who have been waiting for more than a year. (see Waiting Lists for details of metropolitan, regional and rural waiting lists and waiting times)

Health Budget ....

Recurrent spending .....

The NSW government again painted a rosy picture for NSW Health following release of it's 2010-11 budget on June 8th. But the reality is that although the budget increased by 6.8% this will largely be swallowed up by increased cost of salaries, goods and services.

Health expenses increased by 5.52% in 2009 according to the 2008-09 NSW Health Annual Report Three year comparison of key items of expenditure p 232. Applying a 5.52% increase to the operating expenses budget in 2009-10 and comparing it with the funds budgeted this year, it is evident that the extra money amounted to $217.579 million, a mere 1.43% increase.

And $189 million of this money has been provided from Canberra as part of the COAG reforms.  This money will enable the hospital system to operate for five and a half days.

Increase in NSW Health Recurrent Budget required in 2010-11 simply to maintain same level of service as provided in 2009-10
Item:  
$000
1 NSW Health Operating expenses 2009-10 budget (Revised)
$14,455,962
2 5.52% increase in operating expenses NSW Health
$797,969
 
 Therefore 2010-2011 budget required
$15,253,931
3
2010-2011 budget
$15,471,510
Extra money from budget
$217,579*
An increase of:
1.43%
4
Which will enable:
5.4 days extra funding
5
* Includes extra money from COAG
$189,000
 
Sources and Explanatory Notes:
1 Total revised budget for 2009-10 NSW Health Expenses was $14,455,962m according to Budget Estimates 2010-11 p 5-31
2 There was a 5.52% Increase in total expenses in 2009 according to the 2008-09 NSW Health Annual Report Three year comparison of key items of expenditure p 232
3 Budget Estimates 2010-11 p 5-31
4 NSW Health National Health Reform Discussion Paper (page 2) - costs $40m per day for goods, services & wages
5 22 APRIL 2010 Premier KRISTINA KENEALLY told Parliament: 'In 2010-11, $189 million will flow into the system for recurrent expenditure and $134 million for capital expenditure. The New South Wales health budget will receive $278 million over the next financial year.'

Surprisingly, given Premier Keneally's claim she would focus on providing care for the most vulnerable, the two health programs in which funding was not fully spent in 2009-10 were Aboriginal Health Programs and Mental Health Programs.

The Aboriginal Health Budget was underspent by $4.6 million (5%). Factoring CPI, the 2010-11 Budget versus the 2009-10 Budget is actually a decrease of 0.25% or $205,000.  See the figures below which are from page 5-24 Budget Estimates 2010-11.

abhealthbudget

The Mental Health Budget was underspent by $15.5 million (1%).  See figures below from page 5-28 Budget Estimates 2010-11.

mentalhealthbudgetheadmentalhealthbudget

And this year's budget papers have failed to report important performance measures highlighted in last year's budget papers including:

1. Fall injuries (hospitalisations for people aged 65 years and over) - Forecast to be 2,334 for males and 3,173 for females the year.
2. Unplanned and unexpected hospital re‑admission within 28 days - Forecast to be 6.1% this year.
3. Emergency Admission Performance (% treated within 8 hours) - Forecast to be 75% this year.
4. Unplanned and unexpected hospital readmission within 28 days of separation - Forecast to be 6.1% this year.
5. Low birth weight babies (< 2,500g) - Forecast to be 11.5% for Aboriginals and 6% for non-Aboriginals this year.
6. Postnatal home visits (offered a visit within 2 weeks of birth) - Forecast to be 95% this year.
7. Age standardised mortality rate in females aged 50- 69 for breast cancer per 100,000 - Forecast to be 43% this year.

Investment in Infrastructure ....

Last year saw a record low in funding for health infrastructure projects, but despite this there was a 22 year blowout in infrastructure between 09/10 and 10/11 budget and a $77.123 million blowout in infrastructure between 09/10 and 10/11 budget.

INCREASED COST AND DELAYS IN HEALTH INFRASTRUCTURE PROJECTS
 
Completion 09/10
Completion 10/11
Delay (yrs)
Est cost 09/10
Est cost 10/11
Blowout
INFORMATION COMMUNICATION AND TECHNOLOGY
CORPORATE SYSTEMS STAGE 2
2015
2014
-1
-
107,716
na
MEDICAL IMAGING INFORMATION SYSTEM
2011
2012
1
62,867
61,645
-1,222
PATIENT AND CLINICAL SYSTEMS PHASE 2
2010
2011
1
115,000
115,000
0
HEALTH TECHNOLOGY PROGRAM
HEALTH TECHNOLOGY PROGRAM DIAGNOSTIC TREATMENT EQUIPMENT
2010
2011
1
-
7,500
na
KOGARAH EARLY CHILDHOOD CENTRE
2010
2011
1
-
200
na
NARRABRI HOSPITAL REDEVELOPMENT
2012
2012
0
-
41,690
na
NEPEAN HOSPITAL REDEVELOPMENT STAGE 3
2013
2013
0
-
83,502
na
RURAL HOSPITAL AND HEALTH SERVICE
COONAMBLE MULTI-PURPOSE SERVICE (MPS)/HEALTHONE
2011
2011
0
13,900
14,551
651
MANILLA MULTI-PURPOSE SERVICE (MPS)/HEALTHONE
2013
2012
-1
-
19,305
na
AMBULANCE INFRASTRUCTURE
AMBULANCE STATION UPGRADE - NELSON BAY
2010
2011
1
1,030
1,664
634
BATEMANS BAY AMBULANCE STATION
2011
2011
0
1,300
1,907
607
FLEET REPLACEMENT
2012
2011
-1
35,000
38,770
3,770
AUBURN HEALTH SERVICES REDEVELOPMENT
2012
2011
-1
145,100
129,659
-15,441
BREAST CANCER SCREENING
2011
2013
2
19,220
36,942
17,722
HYPERBARIC CHAMBER PRINCE OF WALES HOSPITAL
2010
2011
1
7,623
7,623
0
LISMORE INTEGRATED CANCER CARE
2010
2011
1
27,000
27,000
0
LIVERPOOL HOSPITAL REDEVELOPMENT STAGE 2
2012
2012
0
394,459
395,852
1,393
MAITLAND HOSPITAL EMERGENCY DEPARTMENT
2010
2011
1
10,000
10,000
0
MANNING BASE HOSPITAL EMERGENCY DEPARTMENT
2010
2011
1
13,279
13,279
0
MENTAL HEALTH PROJECTS
PRINCE OF WALES PSYCHIATRIC EMERGENCY CARE CENTRE
2010
2011
1
2,630
2,630
0
SHELLHARBOUR HOSPITAL CHILD AND ADOLESCENT INPATIENT
2010
2011
1
4,400
4,400
0
SYDNEY CHILDREN'S HOSPITAL CHILD AND ADOLESCENT INPATIENT
2011
2013
2
10,277
27,727
17,450
MULTI-PURPOSE SERVICES (MPS) AND HEALTHONE NSW
BALRANALD MPS
2011
2012
1
16,589
16,314
-275
EUGOWRA MPS
2010
2011
1
7,722
7,997
275
OTHER MPS AND HEALTHONE NSW
2012
2013
1
37,032
36,324
-708
NORTHERN BEACHES PRIVATE SITE ACQUISITION
2010
2011
1
-
1,348
na
PROVISION FOR HEALTH INFRASTRUCTURE TRANSITION COSTS
2012
2012
0
35,650
33,651
-1,999
PUBLIC PRIVATE PARTNERSHIPS (PPP) - CYCLICAL MAINTENANCE
LONG BAY FORENSIC HOSPITAL CYCLICAL MAINTENANCE
2018
2018
0
10,132
12,718
2,586
NEWCASTLE MATER HOSPITAL CYCLICAL MAINTENANCE
2018
2018
0
24,088
24,873
785
ORANGE BASE HOSPITAL CYCLICAL MAINTENANCE
2018
2018
0
47,502
55,429
7,927
ROYAL NORTH SHORE HOSPITAL CYCLICAL MAINTENANCE
2018
2018
0
55,505
62,377
6,872
QUEANBEYAN HOSPITAL RENAL SERVICES
2010
2011
1
900
900
0
SHARED CORPORATE SERVICES
2011
2011
0
56,558
56,560
2
STATEWIDE PLANNING AND ASSET MAINTENANCE
2013
2013
0
53,971
53,971
0
ORANGE / BLOOMFIELD REDEVELOPMENT*
ORANGE / BLOOMFIELD REDEVELOPMENT PUBLIC PRIVATE PARTNERSHIP (PPP)
2011
2011
0
162,092
162,091
-1
ORANGE BASE HOSPITAL/BLOOMFIELD REDEVELOPMENT RETAINED WORKS
2012
2012
0
68,053
74,062
6,009
ROYAL NORTH SHORE HOSPITAL (RNSH) REDEVELOPMENT**
RNSH COMMUNITY HEALTH SERVICES (RETAINED COSTS)
2013
2015
2
151,197
158,637
7,440
RNSH RESEARCH AND EDUCATION BUILDING
2010
2011
1
100,179
100,179
0
CANCER INSTITUTE NSW
INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY ENHANCEMENTS FOR CANCER PROGRAMS
2011
2014
3
5,838
8,838
3,000
TOTAL YEAR DELAY
22
TOTAL BLOWOUT
$77,123,000

And despite announcing the start of many hospital upgrades promised years ago, the amount of funding allocated to the projects this year is minimal.

For example:

COMPLETION DUE
ESTIMATED TOTAL COST
ALLOCATION 2010-11
PROJECT DESCRIPTION
$000
$000
DUBBO HEALTH SERVICE STAGE 1
2014
22,734
232
NORTHERN BEACHES REDEVELOPMENT STAGE 1
2014
29,000
5,000
TAMWORTH HOSPITAL STAGE 2 - MATERNITY REFURBISHMENT
2013
10,552
843
WAGGA WAGGA BASE HOSPITAL REDEVELOPMENT STATE 1
2014
90,000
5,091
TOTAL:
152,286
11,166

The last time the NSW Liberal/Nationals were in government it was 11%.

Health’s percentage of the total State Budget infrastructure spend

94/95

03/04

04/05

05/06

06/07

07/08

08/09

09/10

10/11

11%

6.4%

8.1%

7.9%

5.8%

5.2%

5.6%

3.4%

5.6%

 

 

 

3/40 Yeo Street, Neutral Bay 2089. Ph: 9909 2594 Fax: 9909 2654 Email: Jillian.Skinner@parliament.nsw.gov.au